Skip to main content

Full text of "Knight Letter No. 18"

See other formats


3SS& 


THE  LEWIS  CARROLL  SOCIETY    ff^^'flB     OF  NORTH  AMERICA 


^x^^ 


Number  18  February  1983 


Special  Notice:  In  an  effort  to  make  the  Knight  Letter  more  useful  and  informative,  we  would  like  to  solicit  your  aid  in 
publishing  it  more  frequently.  Please  send  any  comments,  useful  information,  or  other  contributions  to  the  editor,  Sandor 
Burstein,  2233  Post  Street,  San  Francisco,  CA  94115. 

Notice  #2:  Annual  dues  are  now  payable.  Please  send  your  checks  to  the  Secretary,  LCSNA,  61 7  Rockford  Road,  Silver 
Spring,  MD  20902,  in  order  to  ensure  your  continued  membership,  mailings  of  the  Knight  Letter,  and  receipt  of  the  next 
publication.  Regular  memberships:  $15  per  annum;  Sustaining  memberships,  $50  per  annum. 

The  Fall  meeting  of  the  Society  was  held  in  the  beautifully  panelled  and  elegantly  furnished  Trustee  Room  of  the  New  York  Public  Library 
on  December  11,  1982.  President  Schaefer  opened  the  proceedings  with  some  announcements,  and  then  introduced  Dr.  Ernest  Abeles  and 
his  wife,  Professor  Francine  Abeles.  Using  remarkable  photographic  slides,  the  Abeles  duo  reported  on  their  week-long  walk  in  the  footsteps 
of  Deacon  Dodgson  during  the  Society's  pilgrimage  to  England  last  Summer.  Shown  were  Tom  Quad,  Dodgson's  room  and  photographic 
studio,  Hall,  the  Deanery,  Binsey,  Godstow  and  Nuneham  along  the  Thames,  the  Ashmolean  Museum  and  the  Bodleian  Library,  Christ 
Church  Cathedral,  and  Brighton.  Mrs.  Abeles'  commentaries  made  the  pictorial  record  part  of  an  unforgettable  experience.  Those  of  us  not 
fortunate  enough  to  have  made  the  trip  were  partially  compensated  by  reliving  the  memories  with  those  who  went. 

Some  twenty-five  pilgrims  travelled  from  the  United  States  and  Canada,  and  were  joined  by  two  brave  souls  from  Japan.  A  particular 
high-point  was  the  visit  to  Dr.  Selwyn  Goodacre's  home  and  enjoying  his  fabulous  collection  and  his  gracious  hospitality  not  only  to  our 
Society,  but  to  members  of  the  Daresbury  and  London-based  Societies.  The  group  portraits  taken  by  Dr.  Abeles  should  be  of  great  historic 
interest,  and  it  is  to  be  hoped  that  he  will  be  able  to  have  copies  made  available. 

Dr.  Joyce  Hines  continued  the  tale  with  a  report  on  the  meaning  of  the  Oxford  Common  Rooms  during  Victorian  times,  as  related  to  older 
traditions,  and  how  it  has  been  continued  in  our  era.  Her  report  of  the  Society's  visit  to  Christ  Church  and  her  own  feelings  and  sentiments 
were  greatly  appreciated. 

Next  on  the  agenda  was  a  short  business  meeting,  and  the  election  of  the  Society's  officers.  By  unanimous  consent,  Maxine  Schaefer  was 
re-elected  Secretary,  and  Raymond  Wapner  the  Treasurer.  Mrs.  Janet  Jurist  accepted  the  new  position  of  Program  Director.  August  I. 
Imholtz,  Jr.  became  the  new  Vice-President,  and  Sandor  G.  Burstein  accepted  the  Editorship  of  the  Knight  Letter  and  the  Presidency. 

Earlier  we  had  been  welcomed  by  Francis  Mattson,  Curator  of  Rare  Books  for  the  NY  Public  Library,  who  had  made  all  the  meeting 
arrangements,  and  had  prepared  a  lovely  little  exhibition  of  memorabilia  from  earlier  LeGallienne  productions  of  Alice.  He  had  also  obtained 
some  proof  sheets  from  Barry  Moser's  forthcoming  Through  the  Looking  Glass  and  was  able  to  show  them.  He  at  this  time  introduced  Dr. 
Vartan  Gregorian,  Director  of  the  Library,  who  welcomed  the  group  most  graciously,  and  extended  warm  invitations  to  return.  We  are  all  most 
grateful  to  these  two  fine  gentlemen,  and  will  feel  quite  comfortable  in  accepting  their  offers  for  the  future. 

Miss  Sabra  Jones,  producer  of  Eva  LeGallienne's  revived  Alice  in  Wonderland  musical  play,  discussed  the  history  of  the  production  and  her 
own  roles  in  this  fiftieth  anniversary  re-creation.  Her  personal  and  intimate  reminiscences  of  Miss  LeGallienne  were  joyously  received.  The 
insight  she  gave  into  the  difficulties  of  financing  a  Broadway  play  was  remarkable.  Stories  such  as  having  to  imagine  and  rewrite  the 
orchestrations  since  the  original  music  had  been  lost  gave  fuel  to  the  fiery  desires  to  see  the  play. 

The  next  speaker,  heralded  by  announcements  of  mystery,  was  our  very  own  Professor  Edward  Giuliano!  In  his  usual  erudite  and  witty 
manner  he  investigated  use  of  symbols  and  meaning  in  the  works  of  Carroll  under  the  formal  title  of  "Semiotics".  Dr.  Giuliano's  thorough 


explanations  produced  much  thinking  as  judged  by  the  number  and  quality  of  comments  and  questions  from  the  audience.  We  all  anticipate 
with  pleasure  the  publication  of  this  talk  so  that  it  can  be  read,  and  reread  and  digested  as  it  deserves.  Sadly,  the  discussion  had  to  be 
truncated  in  order  for  the  group  to  reach  the  restaurant  in  time. 

Dinner  in  the  Italian  manner  at  the  Cheers  Restaurant  (not  the  bar  of  the  television  series)  gave  opportunities  for  socializing  and  renewing 
friendships.  Afterwards,  some  fifty  members  proceeded  to  the  Virginia  Theater  for  the  Alice  in  Wonderland  performance.  Most  comments 
were  favorable,  and  Tenniel  and  Carroll  seemed  to  be  faithfully  represented. 

Miss  LeGallienne  with  great  charm  and  grace  consented  to  receive  a  small  delegation  from  the  LCSNA  after  the  performance.  Stan  Marx 
thanked  her  on  behalf  of  the  Society,  and  gave  her  a  plaque  reading:  "Presented  to  Eva  LeGallienne  in  recognition  of  her  devotion  to  'Alice  in 
Wonderland'  on  the  occasion  of  the  1982  revival  of  the  play.  The  Lewis  Carroll  Society  of  North  America." 

In  addition,  on  authorization  of  the  Executive  Committee,  the  president  asked  Miss  LeGallienne  is  she  would  accept  honorable 
membership  in  the  Society.  With  her  consent,  then,  she  became  the  third  recipient  of  this  tribute.  (Arthur  Houghton  and  Norman  Armour 
were  also  honorary  members. )  Alice  Berkey  will  prepare  a  certificate  to  formalize  this  event. 

Our  Next  Meeting  Is  Tentatively  Planned  For  May  28,  1 983  In  The  Folger  Shakespeare  Library  In  Washington,  D.C.  Please 
Save  This  Date.  A  Stimulating  Program  Is  Being  Prepared.  Further  Details  Will  Be  Forthcoming. 

Diversions  and  Digressions: 

David  and  Maxine  Schaefer  returned  to  London  for  the  dedication  of  the  Lewis  Carroll  stone  in  Poet's  Corner  of  Westminster  Abbey  on 
December  17th  last,  and  represented  the  LCSNA  with  glory.  An  impressive  program  from  the  occasion  includes  a  short  introductory 
biography  by  Selwyn  Goodacre,  lists  the  order  of  the  Evensong  Service,  and  records  the  hymns  and  prayers  as  they  were  presented.  The 
Reverend  Ivor  Davies  addressed  the  congregants  who  afterwards  moved  to  the  Memorial  Stone  where  Brian  Sibley  read  from  the  last  chapter 
of  AAIW.  Mr.  Philip  Dodgson  Jaques,  great-nephew  of  CLD  unveiled  the  stone,  and  Ms.  Lindsay  Fulcher  offered  the  stone  to  the  Dean  in  the 
name  of  the  Lewis  Carroll  Society.  Misses  Holly  and  Kirsten  Luke,  granddaughters  of  Mr.  Jaques  lay  flowers  on  the  stone,  and  were  followed 
by  the  Schaefers  who  presented  a  tiger-lily  wreath  in  the  name  of  our  society.  The  services  concluded,  honored  guests  were  received  in  Bishop 
Partridge  Hall  in  the  Dean's  Courtyard.  A  short  message  from  the  LCSNA  was  read  at  this  time,  expressing  our  thanks  to  our  colleagues  in 
England  who  had  crusaded  for  five  long  years  to  make  this  event  possible.  Television  camera  crews  recorded  portions  of  the  festivities,  and  a 
short  segment  of  some  of  the  highlights  was  seen  on  the  evening  networks  here,  next  day.  It  is  rumored  that  the  Schaefers  have  a  videotape  of 
the  event  to  add  to  their  collection.  Mollie  Panter-Downes'  "Letter  From  London"  in  the  January  31,  1983  New  Yorker  is  devoted  to  the 
ceremony  and  must  be  read  by  all. 

The  Society's  current  publication,  The  Soaring  of  the  Dodo,  should  be  distributed  by  the  end  of  February  to  all  paid-up  members.  Edward 
Giuliano  and  James  Kincaid  edited  the  special  December  issue  of  English  Language  Notes  from  which  our  hardcover  version  has  been  taken. 
Copies  of  the  original  journal  are  available  from  Miss  Pat  McEahern,  English  Language  Notes,  Department  of  English,  University  of 
Colorado,  Boulder,  CO  80309.  Checks  for  S3. 50  should  be  made  out  to  English  Language  Notes. 

Dr.  Giuliano's  "The  Complete  Illustrated  Works  of  Lewis  Carroll"  published  by  Avenel  in  the  U.S.  is  a  great  bargain  and  a  must-purchase  at 
$7.98.  Ed's  selections  and  introduction  are  absolutely  perfect.  Also  available  is  the  Chancellor  Press  version  from  England  at  $7.95  from 
Barnes  &  Noble. 

Alice's  Adventures  in  Jurisprudencia  is  written  by  an  attorney  much  taken  by  Humpty  Dumpty  and  the  distortions  of  meaning  found  in  our 
law-courts.  Nicely  illustrated  by  Sally  Richardson,  it  is  available  from  the  author,  Peter  F.  Sloss,  through  the  Borogove  Press,  78  Bay  View 
Avenue,  Belvedere,  CA  94920.  Price:  $4.95  in  wrappers.  The  name  of  the  press  alone  promises  great  things. 

William  Kaufmann's  Centennial  Edition  of  the  Hunting  of  the  Snarh  is  still  available  from  the  publisher  in  Subscriber's  and  Collector's 
Editions  at  the  original  prices.  The  trade  edition  at  $18.95  is  also  well  worth  having.  Martin  Gardner  updated  his  annotations,  and  Selwyn 
Goodacre  listed  Snark  editions  in  a  terminal  essay.  NOW,  the  first  printing  of  the  trade  edition  contained  eight  egregious  errors  which  were 
corrected  in  the  second  printing.  Speculators  and  investors  in  rare  book  mistakes  should  be  delighted  that  the  first  printing  has  been 
remaindered  for  $7.98  and  is  bound  to  be  a  collector's  rarity.  It  can  be  identified  by  the  lack  of  blurbs  on  the  inner  jackets,  and  by  the 
reproduction  of  the  first  edition  of  the  Snark  at  the  beginning  of  the  book.  If  you  cannot  find  a  copy,  write  to  the  publisher  at  95  First  Street, 
Los  Altos,  CA  94022.  Mark  Burstein  has  written  a  glowing  review  of  the  book  for  Fine  Print,  vol.  8,  #4,  October,  1982.  $7.50  per  issue, 
P.O.  Box  3394,  San  Francisco,  CA  94119. 

Also  in  Fine  Print,  this  time  in  vol.  8,  #3,  for  July  1982  is  Dr.  Giuliano's  four-page  review  of  Barry  Moser's  Pennyroyal  Alice.  There  couldn't 


be  anyone  who  hasn't  seen  either  the  $1000-plus  hook,  the  University  of  California's  Collector's  Edition  at  $195,  or  the  trade  edition  at 
$19.95-24.95.  This  book  is  not  for  children,  but  every  adult  should  have  several  copies.  Mr.  Moser  has  promised  recently  that  the  $15(X) 
Looking  Glass  will  be  released  earlier  than  July. 

Alice  in  Pnzzleland  by  Raymond  Smullyan,  "A  Carrollian  Tale  for  Children  Under  Eighty",  with  an  introduction  by  Martin  Gardner  and 
illustrated  by  Greer  Fitting  has  been  published  by  William  Morrow  at  $12.50.  This  is  a  simply  delightful  collection  of  puzzles,  logical  and 
metalogical  problems,  and  dark  philosophical  paradoxes.  CLD  would  have  loved  it. 

William  Rushton  reads  Alice  in  Wonderland  on  a  two-cassette  package  from  Listen  For  Pleasure,  Ltd. ,  of  Canada,  #7063,  mono,  at  your  book 
or  record  store  for  about  $13. 

Cassette  Classics  from  The  Mind's  Eye,  P.O.  Box  6727,  San  Francisco,  CA  94101,  also  has  two  cassettes:  one  Alice,  and  one  Looking  Glass . 
Introductory  price  is  $4.95  each. 

Cassette  Productions,  811  South  500  West,  Bountiful,  Utah  84010  has  produced  AAIW  and  TTLG  unabridged  on  cassette  tapes  as  read  by 
Professors  Richard  and  Marilyn  Scharine  of  the  University  of  Utah.  These  sell  for  $7.95  per  set  (less  25%  for  Society  Members,  or  $5.96)  plus 
$1.50  for  postage. 

The  World  of  Entertainment:  (Audio-visual  department) 

The  Public  Broadcasting  Service's  Movie  of  the  Week  for  the  last  of  December  was  a  series  of  Betty  Boop  cartoons.  Included  prominently  was 
"Betty  in  Blunderland". 

On  January  2nd,  the  ABC  television  network  program,  "Ripley's  Believe  It  or  Not"  re-created  the  Golden  Afternoon  on  the  Isis.  Jack  Palance 
narrated  the  story,  gave  a  short  word-picture  of  Carroll,  and  showed  a  smiling  Alice  listening  to  every  word.  Film  clips  from  the  Charlotte 
Henry  classic  were  interspersed  into  the  tale,  and  the  fateful  auction  during  which  Dr.  Rosenbach  bought  the  manuscript  was  shown.  This 
scene  even  had  a  smiling  Mrs.  Hargreaves  portrayed.  Credit  for  the  publication  of  AAIW  was  given  to  the  urgings  of  Henry  Kingsley  alone, 
but  otherwise  it  was  more  believable  than  not. 

Alice  in  Blunderland,  an  antinuclear  musical  play  was  seen  in  several  cities  in  Ohio  during  the  summer.  Legacy,  Inc.  sponsored  the 
production,  and  plans  to  show  it  to  Congress  this  Spring.  A  short  version  was  recorded  by  Audio  Recording  Studios  in  Cleveland.  The  editor 
has  not  been  able  to  track  down  any  further  data  and  would  appreciate  assistance  in  finding  a  source  for  the  record. 

Mark  Burstein  presented  an  illustrated  lecture  on  "Aliceology"  to  the  Chapin  School  in  New  York  last  winter.  A  report  was  published  in  the 
Chapin  Limelight  for  April  1982. 

Also  Noted:  AAIW  was  given  daily  by  the  San  Francisco  Shakespeare  Company  in  Levi  Plaza  during  the  last  two  weeks  of  December.  No 
reviews  are  available.  AIW  by  the  City  of  Toronto  Ballet  opened  October  16th  in  Syracuse,  New  York.  TTLG,  an  exhibit  found  at 
Wistariahurst  Museum,  Holyoke,  Mass,  Nov-Dec  '82,  featured  Moser  engravings  and  old  movies.  Morton  Cohen  lectured  on  Lewis  Carroll 
and  His  World  for  the  Smithsonian  Institution  on  October  21st.  Valerie  Bierman  of  the  Edinburgh  Children's  Book  Group  sent  a  Carrollian 
exhibition  throughout  Scotland  from  May  to  October  which  included  items  from  Dodgson  family  collections.  Scientific  American  Medicine's 
1982  chapter  on  Neurology  mentions  the  "Alice  in  Wonderland  Syndrome".  Mad  Magazine  for  September  '82  has  a  parody  of  "60  Minutes" 
with  many  Alician  characters  looking  at  nuclear  power.  Columbia  University's  Alumni  magazine  for  June  '82  relives  the  1932  exhibit  and 
ceremonies  of  that  frabjous  day  when  Alice  Hargreaves  came  to  town.  Douglas  Adams'  series  of  novels,  dramatized  on  public  TV  as  "The 
Hitchhiker's  Guide  to  The  Galaxy"  has  scattered  Carrollian  themes,  often  lightly  disguised:  e.g.,  the  answer  to  the  ultimate  question  of  Life, 
the  Universe,  and  Everything  is  "42". 

The  Stamp  Collector  for  July  12,  1982  featured  the  British  Post  Office's  Alice  stamp,  and  a  fairly  long  story  about  Carroll  next  to  a  recipe  for 
the  orange  marmalade  encountered  during  "the  fall". 

Ken  Oultram  of  the  Lewis  Carroll  Society  of  Daresbury  asks  if  anyone  knows  the  location  of  a  photograph  taken  by  LC  of  Walton  Hall  near 
Warrington  around  1860?  The  picture  is  believed  to  be  in  the  U.S.  (Clatterwick  Hall,  Little  Leigh,  Northwich,  Cheshire,  England.) 

Please  Do  Not  Buy  "Queen  of  Hearts"  by  Kaye  Dobkin,  Dell/Danbury,  $3.50.  This  outrageous  piece  of  trash  has  the  ghost  of  CLD  attempting 
rape  of  a  modern  pre-pubescent  Alice,  and  then  inciting  her  to  murder!  Your  editor  threw  up. 


More  Bargains: 

Dr.  Morton  Cohen's  fabulous  two-volume  collection  of  "The  Letters  of  Lewis  Carroll"  has  been  reduced  from  $60  to  $12.98. 

TennieVs  Alice,  edited  by  Garvey  and  Bond,  reduced  to  $3.50  at  the  Metropolitan  Museum  Shop.  (Wrappers) 

"Grandville's  Animals"  by  Holme,  $8.95,  and  Grandvilles'  Collected  Works  (in  German)  reduced  to  $19.98  (two  volumes).  Grandville's 
animal-people  hive  been  accused  of  being  the  models  for  the  Tenniel  drawings  and  Carroll's  sketches. 

"Camera,  Victorian  Eyewitness'  by  MacDonald,  down  to  $9.95.  Julia  Cameron's  photo  of  Alice  Liddell  is  on  the  jacket  and  there  are  CLD 
photos  inside. 

"The  Gardener's  Song",  from  an  edition  limited  to  99  copies,  is  available  from  Joseph  Vogel,  26  W.  Dunedin  Rd. ,  Columbus,  Ohio  43214. 
Each  page  is  done  in  different  hand-lettering  by  this  77-year  old  artist.  Originally  $30,  now  $25,  this  edition  is  worth  seeing.  Mr.  Vogel  has 
also  done  the  Jabberwocky,  and  promises  a  full  refund  if  the  books  are  returned  for  any  reason.  Libraries  at  both  Harvard  and  Princeton 
have  copies. 

Messner's  Classic  Editions  published  by  Simon  &  Schuster  released  AAIW  and  TTLG  in  a  handsome  volume  illustrated  by  John  Speirs  just  in 
time  for  Christmas  last.  "Filled  with  unexpected  whimsical  details  and  lyrically  magical  renditions  of  the  characters,  this  book  absolutely 
sparkles."  The  "fantasy  drawings"  are  not  always  near  the  section  of  text  to  which  they  relate,  but  otherwise  this  is  a  significant  new  set  of 
artistic  interpretations.  $14.95 

Ivor  Wynne  Jones,  our  correspondent  in  Wales,  has  designed  stamps  for  the  Llechwedd  Slate  Caverns  Railway  Underground  Post 
commemorating  the  150th  birthday  of  LC  and  the  130th  of  Alice  Liddell.  Bilingual  sheets  of  the  stamps  are  available  from  the  Lelchwedd 
Slate  Caverns,  Blaenau  Ffestinoig,  Gwynedd,  LL41  4NB,  Wales,  U.K.  Specify  the  Alice  Issue.  $2.50  includes  the  airmail  postage. 

Charles  M.  Ware,  127B  Arkansas  Street,  San  Francisco,  CA  94107,  is  offering  Society  members  large  discounts  on  his  superb,  fantastic 
Alician  art.  The  Alice  Suite,  ten  etchings  and  engravings  on  Arches  paper,  have  been  sold  for  $125  each  and  are  now  $75  a  sheet.  Larger  and 
smaller  works  in  various  media  are  $35  to  $350  each,  and  each  is  a  signed,  limited  edition,  original  graphic  production.  Mr.  Ware's  sci-fi  and 
fantasy  works  have  been  widely  displayed,  and  are  much  sought-after.  Write  to  the  artist  (or  to  the  editor)  for  a  descriptive  list. 

Milli  Graffi  of  Milan  has  an  interesting  new  Snark.  Copies  may  be  ordered  from  Rocco  Fontana,  Edizione  del  Labirinto,  via  Rosario  7,  75100 
Matera,  Italy.  Ask  for  the  Carta  Scoperte  with  the  Snualo.  L.  10,000  plus  postage. 

The  Knight  Letter  is  the  official  newsletter  of  the  Lewis  Carroll  Society  of  North  America  and  is  distributed  free  to  all  members .  It  is  edited  bySandor  Burstein,  in  cooperation  with  the 
Society's  Editorial  Board.  Subscriptions,  business  correspondence  and  inquiries  should  be  addressed  to  the  Secretary,  The  Lewis  Carroll  Society  of  North  America,  61 7  Rockford 
Road,  Silver  Spring,  MD  20902 .  Submissions  and  editorial  correspondence  should  be  addressed  to  Dr.  Sandor  G .  Burstein,  Editor,  The  Knight  Letter,  2233  Post  Street,  Suite  102, 
San  Francisco,  CA  94115. 


Lewis  Carroll  Society  of  North  America  Non-Profit  Org. 

617  Rockford  Road  U.S.  Postage 

Silver  Spring,  MD  20902  PAID 

Permit  No.  2815 
Silver  Spring,  MD